Iranian Human Rights – A Startling Analysis of the Status

Iranian human rights poor record and troubled history, encompass an array of concerns. They include the criminal justice system, freedom of expression, and treatment of activists and minorities. The authorities have been harsh on peaceful dissenters, human rights defenders, and dissidents.

But those who violate human rights often enjoy impunity. Within this environment, citizens face considerable challenges in their pursuit of justice. And Iran is one of the countries falling short of adherence to international human rights standards.

Iran meets public expressions of dissatisfaction with its policies and practices with harsh retaliation. Security forces and intelligence agencies have used excessive force to squash instances of civil unrest and protests. Activists and dissenters who attempt to bring attention to these abuses often face severe repercussions, such as arbitrary detention and unfair trials. Minority groups, particularly ethnic and religious minorities, also experience discrimination, further highlighting the concerning state of human rights in Iran.

Historical Overview of Iranian Human Rights

Iranian human rights has been a subject of concern for many years. Since the Iranian Revolution  in 1979, the Islamic Republic of Iran has been criticised for its record on civil liberties, political freedoms, and gender equality. The foundation of the Islamic Republic system dramatically changed the political landscape and affected the Iranian human rights situation.

During the Pahlavi dynasty, Iran was known for its royal dictatorship. Iran employed secret police, torture, and executions to suppress political dissent. The Islamic Revolution aimed to change this oppressive system and establish a new government based on Islamic principles. But despite this, the human rights situation did not improve significantly.

Under the Islamic Republic of Iran, Iranian authorities continued to crack down on dissent and restrict the fundamental rights of their citizens. Political activists, journalists, and minority communities faced constant persecution and intimidation. There are still heavy restrictions on freedom of expression, association, and assembly. Many individuals have had lengthy prison sentences or execution for their activities.

The Islamic Republic system has faced many popular uprisings, with citizens demanding social, economic, and political reforms. Security forces have always responded with excessive force, using live ammunition and metal pellets to disperse protesters. Hundreds, if not thousands, of individuals have lost their lives in these confrontations, with many more injured or imprisoned.

Despite numerous calls from the international community and human rights organisations, the government has shown little willingness to address the Iranian human rights issues. And it continues to maintain its strict control over the population. The future of human rights in Iran remains uncertain. Many citizens live in fear of persecution or violence for expressing their beliefs or opinions.

Criminal Justice System

The criminal justice system in Iran is complex and dysfunctional. The Iranian judiciary plays a pivotal role in perpetuating human rights violations. It has been criticised for lacking independence. This often results in unfair trials and arbitrary punishments administered by the state.

Process of Arrest and Detention

One of the main issues surrounding the Iranian justice system is the process of arrest and detention. They have arrested many on vague indictments, such as disrupting national security. And they often remand them in custody without making formal charges for extended periods. In some cases, detainees experience physical and psychological abuse at the hands of police and security forces.

Inhumane Penalties

The country’s penal code exacerbates these issues by enshrining laws that violate human rights. For example, the code includes penalties such as amputation and flogging as permissible forms of punishment. The penal code criminalises a wide range of political and social actions. It has enabled authorities to target and punish dissidents, human rights activists, and minority groups disproportionately.

Arbitrary Detention

Human rights organisations have reported suppression of peaceful dissent. There have been numerous cases of arbitrary detention, unfair trials, and punishment of human rights defenders. One such example is the case of narges mohammedi. The Iran authorities released Mohammedi from prison, a prominent human rights defender, in 2020 after more than eight years.

Takeaway

Despite ongoing concerns and calls for reform, the Iranian criminal justice system remains a key factor in perpetuating human rights abuses and denying justice to countless individuals.

Intel Agencies and Security Forces’ Role

Iran’s intelligence agencies and security forces play a significant role in the country’s human rights landscape. One of the principal organisations involved in maintaining the strict regime is the Ministry of Intelligence and Security (MOIS). The agency’s primary focus is on retaining the Islamic regime’s power and control.

Penal Code Misuse

Iran’s judiciary and intelligence agencies have been known to use broad articles of the penal code. Two such articles are propaganda against the state and assembly and collusion to act against national security. They have used them to suppress opposition and stifle dissenting voices. This has resulted in human rights violations, as critics and activists face persecution, imprisonment, and even death.

Disregard for Privacy

The agencies have been accused of engaging in widespread domestic and foreign surveillance. Often with little regard for privacy rights. They report to separate government ministries, branches of the military, and police forces. Thus, making it difficult to hold them accountable for their actions. This lack of transparency and oversight has further contributed to Iran’s poor human rights record.

Excessive Force

Iran’s security forces have been implicated in multiple instances where excessive force was used to quell protests and suppress dissent. For example, during the November 2019 fuel price protests, security forces were accused of using lethal force against unarmed civilians. Media and human rights groups have documented suspicious deaths in custody, as well as beatings of protesters by security forces.

Iranian Ministry of Intelligence and Security

On an international level, the Iranian Ministry of Intelligence and Security (MOIS) has been designated by the U.S. Department of the Treasury for its support of terrorist groups and perpetration of human rights abuses. The IRGC, likewise, has been accused of sponsoring terrorism and engaging in acts that destabilise the region.

Takeaway

Iran’s intelligence agencies and security forces play a significant role in the country’s human rights problems. They have been instrumental in suppressing opposition, violating privacy, and engaging in acts that harm Iranian citizens and regional security.

Freedom of Expression and Media

In recent years, the Iranian authorities have heavily suppressed the rights to freedom of expression. They have banned independent political parties, trade unions, and civil society organisations. And they have censored media outlets and jammed satellite television channels.

The crackdown hasn’t stopped at traditional media sources. The government has also targeted the internet. Iran extensively censors online content, which includes more than 75 unique LGBT+ URLs. The restrictions have severely limited the population’s access to critical news, human rights, and cultural information.

Security forces have used excessive and sometimes lethal force against peaceful assembly and expression. Iranian authorities have cracked down on widespread protests nationwide. These actions led to the further erosion of the rights to freedom of expression, association, and assembly, negatively affecting the daily lives of Iranian citizens.

In response to these challenges, human rights organisations have urged the Iranian government to protect the rights of its citizens and make allowance for freedom of expression and media. However, repression and censorship continued to pose major obstacles for Iranian society, stifling critical voices and denying citizens access to valuable information and perspectives.

Protests and Civil Unrest

Demonstrations, driven by political and economic factors led the Iranian government clamp down on surges in protests and civil unrest. This led to widespread concern among human rights organisations and international bodies about human rights violations in Iran.

One significant event was the violent suppression of civil society in June 2022, as reported by UN independent human rights experts. Protests erupted across the country, demanding government transparency, accountability, and respect for human rights. Aggressive action by security forces against protesters resulted in numerous injuries and fatalities.

Widespread protests intensified following the killing of Mahsa Amini, a 21-year-old Kurdish Iranian woman who was arrested for improper hijab. She was allegedly beaten to death while in custody, according to Time. This tragic incident galvanised the protest movement. And led to an even larger number of people joining the demonstrations and demanding justice for similar victims.

The UN High Commissioner for Human Rights declared Iran to be in a fully-fledged human rights crisis. The reason – because the authorities clamped down on anti-regime dissidents, as stated by CNN. The Human Rights Council even launched an independent investigation into the deadly violence against protesters in the country, according to the United Nations.

These widespread protests and the government’s violent response have brought international attention to Iran’s human rights issues. In a similar vein, Harvard Kennedy School reported that more than 500 protesters, including women and children, were killed during months of unrest. This sparked further calls for action from inside and outside the country. It remains to be seen how these events will shape Iran’s political, social, and human rights landscape in the future.

Treatment of Activists and Dissenters

Iran is well-known for its harsh treatment of activists and dissenters. The government has targeted human rights defenders, environmental advocates, labour rights activists, and any individual voicing concerns about the political and socioeconomic positions held by the government.

According to a World Report published by Human Rights Watch, Iran authorities arrested over 69 workers’ rights activists between May 2021 and 2022. They summoned and interrogated dozens more. In addition to the crackdown on labour rights activists, there were several instances involving arrest and imprisonment of peaceful protesters and individuals advocating for change in other areas.

Amnesty International, a prominent NGO, documented numerous cases of human rights abuses in Iran, including the arbitrary arrest and detention of activists and dissenters. These individuals were subjected to harsh conditions in prison, including prolonged solitary confinement, torture, and denial of medical care.

The Center for Human Rights in Iran (CHRI) is an organisation that focused on documenting human rights abuses. It reported Iran’s restrictions on freedom of expression and the targeting of activists. It included the jailing of environmental and civil society activists accused of vague charges, such as endangering national security or spreading propaganda against the system.

Iranian authorities have been known to use legal and extrajudicial methods to quash dissent, such as banning NGOs or pressuring them to cease their advocacy work. Additionally, activists and dissidents often face difficulties in obtaining fair trials. They are routinely prosecuted in Revolutionary Courts, known for their lack of transparency and due process.

Takeaway

Despite international condemnation, Iran has suppressed the voices and rights of activists and dissenters. The persistence of these practices reflects a wider disregard for the fundamental human rights of its citizens, highlighting the need for continued vigilance and advocacy on this issue.

Discrimination and Minority Rights

In Iran, women, religious minorities, and ethnic minorities experience some of the most notable obstacles to their rights.

Women are subject to entrenched discrimination and violence. The development of the Iranian legislative framework further undermines sexual and reproductive rights. Also, the rights to freedom of religion and belief, and access to the internet.

Iran has frequently disregarded the rights of the religious minorities, and often excludes them from public life and economic development.

Ethnic minorities, such as those living in the Kurdistan region of Iraq or the provinces of Sistan and Baluchistan, have faced discrimination which has contributed to rising tensions and dissatisfaction within the country.

Furthermore, the repression of people speaking and practicing minority languages and cultures, has led to tensions between ethnic and religious groups and the broader Iranian society. Addressing discrimination and protecting minority rights are crucial steps to advancing human rights.

Specific Case Studies

Nasrin Sotoudeh

There are several cases of human rights violation that stand out in Iran. One such case is that of Nasrin Sotoudeh, a prominent Iranian human rights lawyer. They have arrested and detained her on multiple occasions for her advocacy work. Despite widespread international condemnation, she has faced lengthy prison sentences and harsh treatment. This reflected the government’s lack of tolerance for dissent and its willingness to suppress rights defenders.

Amirsalar Davoudi

Another case involves Amirsalar Davoudi, an Iranian lawyer known for representing human rights activists and political prisoners. They sentenced Davoudi to a lengthy prison term on numerous charges related to his representation of clients and the establishment of a channel on the popular messaging app Telegram. His case highlights the challenges faced by lawyers and other professionals advocating for human rights in Iran.

Narges Mohammedi

The plight of Iranian human rights activist and journalist Narges Mohammedi is noteworthy. Mohammadi has faced multiple arrests, detentions, and sentences for her work in advocating for women’s rights and the abolition of the death penalty. Despite the negative impacts on her own health, she has continued her activism while in prison.

Persian Wildlife Heritage Foundation

In another case, the Iranian government targeted the Persian Wildlife Heritage Foundation – an organisation dedicated to the preservation of wildlife and the environment. Several members of the organisation were arrested on charges of espionage, leading to convictions and lengthy prison sentences, despite a lack of credible evidence. This case illustrates the government’s willingness to suppress environmental activism and civil society more broadly.

Sistan and Baluchistan

Sistan and Baluchistan Province  has been a source of concern. This southeastern province of Iran has faced problems, including poverty, drug trafficking, and violence. The government’s heavy-handed response to protests and other expressions of dissatisfaction in the region has resulted in multiple deaths and injuries. The case serves as a reminder of the broader issues faced by marginalised communities within Iran.

Takeaway

The cases outlined above represent just a few examples of human rights challenges faced by Iranians. By shedding light on these cases, we can understand better the depth and scope of the human rights problems in Iran and the importance of continued international attention and advocacy.

Effects on Society

Iranian human rights violations have had far-reaching effects on society. The country’s deteriorating economic conditions, due to US unilateral sanctions and the impact of the Covid-19 pandemic, have increased poverty and reduced living standards for millions of Iranians. This has put great pressure on Iran’s president and parliament to address the issues.

The government’s attempts to suppress peaceful dissent have had a chilling effect on freedom of expression. Iranian authorities have arrested and sentenced human rights defenders to decades-long prison sentences. Threats to their right to peaceful assembly and expression coupled with excessive and lethal force used by security forces, effectively silences critics and stifles free speech.

Poverty, combined with increased suppression of dissent, has had negative consequences for education and medical care. Limited resources and non-improvement of infrastructure have left Iranian society struggling to access quality education and medical care. The Iranian people have faced hardships through the actions of government who have failed to address vital societal needs.

Takeaway

Iranian human rights problems have had significant negative effects on society. Issues range from increased poverty, reduced access to education and medical care, and the suppression of free speech and peaceful dissent. The president, parliament, and other governmental entities must address these concerns to ensure a brighter future for all Iranians.

Towards Transparency and Justice

Iran’s numerous human rights problems means the need for transparency and justice has never been greater. The Iranian Government has a responsibility to promote and protect the rights of its citizens; however, a lack of accountability and widespread impunity continued to hinder progress in this area.

One of the main concerns is the suppression of freedom of expression, association, and assembly. The authorities have banned independent political parties, trade unions and civil society organisations, leading to a restricted environment where dissent is severely punished. Addressing these issues requires increased government transparency as well as the establishment of laws and mechanisms that promote freedom of speech and democratic processes.

In addition, the Iranian judiciary and security apparatus have been harsh on dissent, leading to numerous arrests and convictions without due process. A commitment to justice necessitates reforms in the legal system that ensure all citizens have access to a fair trial and are protected from arbitrary detention.

Moreover, the disturbing rise in drug-related executions has drawn the attention of the United Nations special rapporteur on human rights, as highlighted in their July 2022 report to the General Assembly. Addressing this issue requires a re-evaluation of Iran’s policies on capital punishment and the implementation of more humane and effective approaches to drug control.

Takeaway

Upholding transparency and justice in Iran necessitate a comprehensive approach that addresses structural and systemic issues within the government and judiciary. This includes promoting freedom of expression, increasing government transparency, ensuring due process, and reconsidering capital punishment policies. By taking these steps, Iran can move towards a more just and transparent society, where all citizens are afforded the human rights, they are entitled to.

Frequently Asked Questions

What challenges do women face regarding their rights in Iran?

Women in Iran face multiple challenges regarding their rights, including legal and societal discrimination. Issues such as forced veiling, unequal inheritance rights, and restrictions on employment opportunities contribute to a difficult environment for women to exercise their basic rights and freedoms.

How does the UN address human rights issues in Iran?

The UN addresses human rights issues in Iran through the OHCHR Headquarters and the UN Human Rights Training and Documentation Centre for South-West Asia and the Arab Region. These entities aim to strengthen the promotion and protection of human rights through technical cooperation, capacity building, and national dialogue in Iran.

What is the history of human rights in Iran?

The history of human rights in Iran is marked by periods of progress and regression, with various regimes shaping the trajectory of human rights in the country. Particularly, after the 1979 revolution, Iran saw a shift towards a more conservative approach to human rights, with the implementation of numerous laws and policies that restricted certain freedoms and perpetuated discrimination against certain social groups.

What rights do minorities have in Iran?

Minorities in Iran face significant challenges in achieving equal rights, whether ethnic, religious, or linguistic. Discrimination, marginalisation, and persecution against minority groups have led to limitations on their political representation and access to education, cultural expression, and government services. Some minority groups face even more severe conditions, such as targeted human rights abuses and systemic discrimination.

Is Iran a signatory of the Declaration of Human Rights?

Yes, Iran is a signatory of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, having signed the declaration in 1948 alongside other member states of the United Nations. However, implementation and adherence to the declaration’s provisions have been inconsistent in Iran.

What aspects of Sharia law impact human rights in Iran?

Certain aspects of Sharia law as implemented in Iran impact human rights significantly. For example, harsh punishments such as amputations and floggings for certain crimes, discrimination against women and LGBTQ+ individuals in the legal system, and limitations on freedom of expression and association all contribute to reported human rights violations in Iran. It is important to note, however, that Sharia law’s interpretation and application in Iran is subject to the influence of political and religious authorities, which can vary across time and contexts.

Why not Join Us

If you enjoyed this article, we would like to offer you two gifts – our Starter Pack of 4 James King’s books and our Weekly Digest, which you can receive by email.